Comic Book Clique

REVIEW: The Smart Division #3 - Clubbed to Death

Frank JaromeComment

The Smart Division #3

Writer: Zack Kaplan

Artist: John J. Pearson

Publisher: Dark Horse Comics

"All those... moments... will be lost in time.

Like tears... in... rain."


Party Girl

After being "invited" to a party by MorAIrty, our intrepid detectives were witnesses to multiple murders of high-level Fusion executives.  That's bad.  However, in the aftermath of those killings, the FBI was no longer protecting Fusion, so the detectives were able to get all of their paperwork. That meant fresh leads.

A lead from those files leads them to George Washington University, where nine technology students were given grants to work on the AI projects that led to all of these murders.  Another clue leads Stevie to go rogue and meet the missing Bjorn Frisk on her own, where she gets more pieces of the puzzle before things devolve into a shootout...


Extra Credit

This issue is heavy on the detective work, which starts to pull the various pieces of the mystery together.  It also gives us some more insight into our detectives and how they are learning to interact with each other.

The early scenes play up the differences between the two, as Williams literally paces the room piecing together evidence gathered from Fusion's files while Larque uses AI to sift through contract filings.  We were told how different their approaches to the job were at the start of the series, but it's nice to actually see it in action here instead of just always being told about it.

I liked how one of the most personal conversations between the two partners happened while they were riding on the Merry-Go-Round.  It's just a funny location for such a serious conversation about themselves and their approaches to the case, it's almost surreal.  I enjoyed the understanding that they came to in the aftermath of that conversation—Stevie won't use AI for the rest of the case, if Williams stops being "such a hopeless prick."  The two partners are starting to warm up to and understand each other, and even though a deal like this seems like they're giving each other grief, I think it shows that they're learning how to work together better.

Well, at least I did think that, until Stevie got home and went rogue.  She really is brash and impulsive, making contact with Frisk and wanting to meet with him alone.  The only proof she has that he wasn't the murderer is her gut, so that's a pretty bold move, agreeing to meet him without any backup.  I mean, she apparently didn't know (or care) that the department is monitoring her at all times, so she's going to get that backup anyway—but she may not have known that.

Williams follows her to the club, where he finds himself off-balance enough that he has a drink. Drinking on the job is never good—especially when it turns out that drink was drugged.  And then a shootout starts, which is really not easy to deal with when you've been slipped a mickey and the world looks like it's all in messy watercolors.

What still remains interesting is how Williams is the one who's narrating the issue, telling the story of the investigation and how it all went wrong.  Stevie is nowhere to be found.  Does that mean that she's alive and well, telling her version of events in the next room?  Or does it mean that she's is no longer among the living?  The latter in particular would be an interesting twist, since Williams is the one who ends up shot in the gut this issue (my guess is, that's what leads to him growing the beard—not shaving while recovering).

It can be hard to build tension when your killer is still unknown, and the main antagonist is a faceless AI bot.  This issue has no trouble on that end, neatly establishing the stakes and how complicated a "simple" murder case can really be.  That's very effective work by the creative team.


Just One Drink

Speaking of the creative team, Zack Kaplan turns in a detective story that could be riddled with cliches and technical jargon.  Instead, he gives us strong character work and just enough technical details to make it all seem eerily plausible—but not so much that the story becomes impenetrable without a degree.  Actually, if a story went too far with modern technical jargon, I'm not even sure a degree would help.  I actually have an IT degree myself, and things have changed so much in the twenty years since I got it that I'm not even able to follow all of the new advancements in technology myself...

As strong as the writing is, it's the art by John J. Pearson that really makes this book stand out.  Parts of the book have a sketchy, messy look not unlike Ben Templesmith.  There's a bit of a computerized watercolor look to the art,  which I know sounds like an illogical combination but it's the best way I can explain it.  Other sections, such as when the grant students are interviewed, are done in a more traditional style that is even more messy and traditionally colored in bright primary colors.  Lastly, we have the shootout sequence at the end, which is from the perspective of the drugged Williams.  This section gives up all sense of completion to the art, with unfinished lines, almost melted textures, and colors that don't remotely match what is happening.  It's confusing, it's messy, and it's incredibly unique.


AI Bot

The Smart Division #3 is another strong issue that moves the mystery forward, while our leads come to a bit of an understanding between themselves.  The case itself remains compelling without getting bogged down in technical jargon.  The artwork continues to be experimental and unique, giving the book a feel that doesn't match anything else on the shelves today.


FINAL SCORE: 9 out of 10

Essential