Comic Book Clique

REVIEW: The Doom Patrol #3 - Into the Void

Frank JaromeComment

The Doom Patrol #3

"Only Fear Itself"

Writer: Darcy Van Poelgeest

Artist: Niko Henrichon

Publisher: DC Comics

The strangest superheroes of them all must overcome their issues and work together to save a young girl from a bizarre cult, before it's too late...


Crazy Train

All three members of the Doom Patrol are being forced to relive their greatest fears and pains once more.  This comes at the hands of the villain Phobia, who, along with Warp, is helping the Cult of the Ever-Void.

Negative Man is able to use his new power to bring things back from the mindscape to return something that had been lost to Phobia, removing her from the fight.  That just leaves Warp, and the powers possessed by the young cult member Evelyn—the same girl they were sent to save!

Will the Doom Patrol be able to rescue Evelyn, and will the whole team return from the mission?


Who Are You

This is a hard book to review.  As a stand-alone issue, this is a pretty good one, with solid action and some decent character work.  But as a Doom Patrol story, it's lacking in several areas.

First and foremost, for a series that is supposedly acknowledging their full history and prior incarnations, this version of the team doesn't make a lot of sense.  To be perfectly honest, it feels more based on the TV show than any of the comics runs.  The take presented here has basically reset the team back to factory settings, with Niles Caulder in charge—which, given everything that had been revealed about him over the years, there is no way the team would ever follow him again.

Second, the characters feel almost like Cliff's Notes version of themselves.  The one that has gotten the most attention is Larry/Negative Man, and even he doesn't feel totally right.  It seems like Cliff is actually the one getting the most attention, but then you realize that he's just being angsty the whole time—which doesn't fit his character at all.  And Rita is mean and spiteful, while showing the same insecurities about her looks and powers that she had worked past years ago.

I don't want to sound like I'm doing nothing but bashing this book.  Again, this issue was actually pretty solid.  But the way the series as a whole has been presented so far seems to be heavily at odds with the "everything counts" stance touted by the writer.  It's all just too hard to reconcile.  I think the hardest part to reconcile is the Caulder of it all—if everything that's come before counts, then the team would never give them the time of day.  He lied to them how many times before, never mind the fact that he was directly responsible for all of their accidents that gave them their powers in the first place?  It just doesn't track.

At least we do get some decent action scenes this issue, with the team actually working together and using their powers.  I think that Negative Man's new power is going to get overplayed real quickly, and he's still getting too much of the focus over Cliff and Rita, but it's all at least a step in the right direction.


The Kids Aren't Alright

Darcy Van Poelgeest seems to get the characters at their cores—it just doesn't feel like he's actually using everything that's come before.  In fact, it almost feels like he watched the TV series, skimmed some back issues, and then ran with it.  The villains here, from Phobia and Warp to the Ever-Void cult itself, are all good matches for the Doom Patrol—I just wish the team itself felt more like, well, itself.

The art by Niko Henrichon remains a highlight, although it seems a bit rougher in spots in this issue.  The art is highly detailed, with the characters appearing in versions of their classic looks.  The villains and their various power effects are well-presented, especially Warp's portal effects.  The colors on things like Negative Man and Phobia's power effects stand out and show how bizarre they really are.  Some of the choreography during the big rescue scene is a little hard to follow, and I actually didn't even understand what happened to one character until the dialogue spelled it out for me.  So there are definitely still some rough patches here.


You Can't Always Get What You Want

The Doom Patrol #3 is a decent issue in a series that has been a little disappointing overall.  It's too hard to reconcile what we're getting with the "everything that's come before counts" pitch we were told the series was following in the initial press.  Add to that artwork that is pretty but a bit hard to follow in spots, and you've got a book that is more likely to appeal to fans of the TV show than die-hard fans of the team in all their incarnations.


FINAL SCORE: 6.5 out of 10

Recommended (with caveats)