Comic Book Clique

REVIEW: Nightwing #143 Reunites Nightwing and Robin!

Gabe FosterComment

Release: October 2026 | Writer: Dan Watters | Artist: Denys Cowan | Inker: Norm Rapmund | Colorist: Francesco Segala | Letterer: Wes Abbott

*Nightwing #143 SPOILERS ahead!*

After Gotham has been entrenched in vines, Nightwing is still struggling mentally. Can a little side quest with Damian help ease his struggling mind?


OLD TIME’S SAKE

Gotham is still enclosed in branches from the ground up.

Nightwing meets with Benjamin James in the hospital. For those who don't remember, Benjamin Jones was the man in the truck who attempted to cause an explosion recently. He is a little banged up, but he'll be okay, which Nightwing is relieved about.

Nightwing and Damian get rid of the TNT, but even Robin notices that Nightwing looks not too great.

Things continue to go wrong in the city as it's falling apart. Luckily, they notice that Batgirl is here and stopping as many crimes as she can, while Batman continues to get to the bottom of what's happening here in Gotham.

She transports a sick child to Gotham General while casually sporting a stab wound. Damian notices a 1920s submachine gun at the site of a crash involving a police car. Nightwing knows exactly who is behind this attack. That's because the man driving the car wasn't an officer. It is Paulie Mackie, a man who worked for Scarface, whom Nightwing and Batman put away years ago.

Nightwing meets with Scarface, who is at war with another man named The Minotaur. Luckily while the shootout happens and the bad guys are distracted, Damian is able to knock a car into them, taking them out of the fight long enough for Nightwing to free the hostages who he scolds for their bad life choices.

When Mr. Wesker tries to stop them, he ends up leaving Scarface on the ground. Damian puts a foot over his face, making Mr. Wesker nervous. He points a gun at a diseased officer before Nightwing and Damian release Scarface back to Wesker's possession. The men who were held hostage get their revenge and drop a smoke bomb in the warehouse.

The good guys kick some butt and make it out safe. All in a good day's work.

Damian impresses Nightwing by giving the infected officer some medicine instead of attacking him. Nightwing seems proud of where Damian has ended up since he was working alongside him as Batman in the past.

While Wesker is running away with Scarface, he grabs his wooden head that EXPLODES leaving Wesker upset.


Final Thoughts:

While Nightwing has always been a must-read for me, I think it’s beginning to hit a stretch that I'm not too much of a fan of, sadly.

This book felt like filler to get to the next, when there weren’t many issues like that before. Also, comparing the line work in this one, something just feels off? Or maybe rushed art-wise when it comes to the models of the characters?

Not sure what it is, but it isn't hitting the way it did with the Zanni storyline or even the beginning of this story arc.

Hoping it picks up again, or hoping that this Nightwing depression arc is coming to a conclusion soon, since it may hinder the character if it continues on for too long, I fear.

Overall Score: 6/10