Comic Book Clique

REVIEW: Midnight Fantastic Four #2 - A Hole in the Earth

Frank JaromeComment

Midnight Fantastic Four #2

"The Firmament"

Writer: Benjamin Percy

Artist: Kev Walker

Colorist: Frank D'Armata

Publisher: Marvel Comics

Where the sun and the moon war for the sky, there is a hole in the world...


I Hate All of My Friends

This is a very slow-burn issue that is heavily character-driven, so I'd like to break from my usual story recap format and talk about the characters instead.

Reed Richards: the same brilliant man he's always portrayed as, but here he is addicted to a strange purple pill that allows him to see into other dimensions.  He's been driven by a need to see what's on the other side of the Negative Zone, and he's hurt people—intentionally or not—along the way.  People like...

Victor: Reed's lab assistant; he hails from an unknown Eastern European country.  In a drug haze, Reed opens a portal while Victor is in the blast zone, and the man is left for dead.  His body is returned home to Latveria, where his mother has kept him alive through some Frankenstein-esque means.  All of Victor's bodily fluids are made up of Dark Matter now...

Susan Storm: a billionaire who is also trying to discover the secrets of the Negative Zone, she has recruited Reed and supplied him with the resources he needs to find the answers they both seek.  She also seems to have a growing attraction to Dr. Richards...

Ben Grimm: Susan's bodyguard; he's a man of few words but swift action.  We don't know much about him yet, but he never leaves Sue's side...

Johnny Storm: Susan's younger brother; he wants nothing more than to fly.  He lost both of his legs when he was in the Air Force, after which he was grounded.  Sue lets him fly, but only as long as she finds him useful—which is how Johnny says she treats all people...

Reed, Sue, Ben, and Johnny definitely aren't friends—they're barely coworkers—but they're going to work together to unlock the secrets of the Negative Zone.  Hopefully they survive the experience...


It's Time I Think You Know the Truth

Two issues in, Midnight Fantastic Four has been a very pleasant surprise for me.

The surprise is pleasant, I mean.  The content is definitely not.

When you're presenting an alternate take on something like the Fantastic Four, it's all too easy to keep too many of the core elements intact.  You start doing that, and the final product isn't all that different from the mainline 616 version.  So far, that does not seem to be the case here.

Here, Reed Richards and Ben Grimm are not best friends.  Hell, they barely know or like each other.  Sue and Johnny Storm are siblings, of course, but they are not remotely close.  Johnny seems like he can barely stand his sister, as he's seen how she can chew people up and spit them out.  Reed is on drugs; that's another big one.  There are just so many things, big and small, that make this take on our core elements so very different indeed.

For me, one of the biggest ones with the most potential is Victor.  Although it hasn't been mentioned in the story yet, we all know he's Victor Von Doom.  The lab accident here did a lot more than scar his face—it basically killed him.  And there was no ambiguity here; it was all Reed's fault.  So now Victor is barely clinging to life thanks to some Frankensteinian science performed at the hands of his mother, who is the "armored individual in a green cloak" of this world.  So whether you consider it to be Victor or his mother, here we have a Doom who is completely justified in their blame and hatred of Reed Richards.  In a world that's probably soon to be full of eldritch horrors, that's not a good thing.

When trying to do an alternate take on the FF and present it in a darker manner, it's really easy to go too far and make everyone utterly unlikable. Thankfully, that doesn't seem to be happening here yet.  Don't get me wrong, these still aren't people you're going to have a cup of coffee with, but they're not utter assholes either.  For the most part, you can see how a few different choices could have spun them in a wildly different direction, but the world they're in just doesn't allow that kind of light.

As far as the world itself, here we are introduced to the idea that there are different places where events have weakened the barriers between the Earth and the Negative Zone.  Mt. Tambora and its largest volcanic eruption in history.  The Tunguska event that had the largest asteroid impact in human history.  The Trinity site, where the first nuclear bomb testing occurred.  These are places where there is effectively a hole in the world that allows one to see through to the other side—to the Negative Zone.

That also means that there are multiple places where eldritch horrors can break through if someone is careless and fully opens the door between worlds, but these types of stories aren't very exciting if people are actually careful.


Please Take A Bow

Benjamin Percy is using his horror background to bring a feeling of building dread to this story.  He's also filling it with glimpses or promises of eldritch horrors to come, giving the story that slowly building Lovecraftian feel.  His take on the characters, as I mentioned earlier, starts from a familiar point but then takes them in a different direction, more fitting to the setting.  The story itself is a very slow burn, but I think that's necessary for this kind of tale—without getting to know the characters, without building the tension, the ultimate reveals wouldn't have the same impact.

When Kev Walker was announced as the artist for this book, I thought he was a weird choice for this kind of subject matter.  But he's been pleasantly surprising me so far.  He's building the horror atmosphere very well with his art, using page layouts and camera angles that carry the feeling of dread through them.  The eldritch horrors that we are beginning to glimpse, such as the birds with all of the bizarre tentacles, come across as creepy and alien at the same time.  There's no action to speak of so far; even Ben Grimm taking out the birds is accomplished between panels, but that's just another way the team is building atmosphere.

The colors from Frank D'Armata add another layer to the building tension.  Nothing in this issue can be considered too bright.  Even the daytime scenes still have heavy shadows or fog to them, so nothing ever appears too hopeful in tone.  The purple glow seemingly associated with things of the Negative Zone stands out as clearly alien and wrong, as does the Latverian laboratory that Victor finds himself clinging to life in.  As our group of explorers edges closer to uncovering the secrets of the Negative Zone, I expect that the colors are going to continue growing darker and more unnatural.


It's Too Late For Me Now

Midnight Fantastic Four #2 is an excellent slow-burn issue that builds on the promise of issue #1 by spending more time with our core group of characters and showing how they differ from their mainline versions.  No one here is the kind of person you're going to want to hang out with, but they're not utterly unlikable or irredeemable either.  The horror elements continue to build, with more glimpses of what lies on the other side of the Negative Zone.  If Benjamin Percy and Kev Walker can keep building the tension and sense of dread they've started with here, and don't fumble the big reveal of the Zone itself, this series has the potential to be the strongest of the three Midnight titles.  And that's saying a lot.


FINAL SCORE: 8.5 out of 10

Highly Recommended