Daredevil #9
“City of Fear” Part 2
Writer: Stephanie Phillips
Artist: Lee Garbett
Colorist: Frank Martin
Publisher: Marvel Comics
How do you kill a man without fear?
By putting the fear in him.
Bad Trip
Larry Cranston—Mr. Fear—has taken Matt Murdock's class hostage. Dosing the classroom with his new fear gas, Mr. Fear throws a handful of the drug Valor out into the room, telling everyone they'd best take it to counteract his gas. Matt, of course, refuses...
What follows is a drug-induced trip that is hard to explain. This new version of the fear gas appears to target Matt's personal memories, making him relive all his pain, loss, and guilt—things Matt Murdock has plenty of.
Elsewhere, Detective Forte is still suffering the aftereffects of the trauma Omen inflicted on him, and Mr. Fear's financial backer is revealed—Harlan Vale, the man who has been making waves at ESU of late...
Man with Fear
Yes, earlier I quoted the Ben Affleck-starring Daredevil movie from 2003. I actually kind of liked it—so sue me.
There's nothing like a good drug-trip story, and this is definitely a good one. It's hard to tell what is real and what is the gas, which leaves us as off-balance as Matt throughout the story.
In this age of writers coming onto a book and wanting to make their stamp on a character, too often previous continuity is ignored. So it made me happy to see so much attention given to Matt's ex-wife Milla Donovan here, since Mr. Fear was responsible for her ultimate fate. I'm still not sold on the villain's new look, but his character is certainly intact, and that's what really matters.
As I said earlier, it's hard to describe much of this issue, with the drug rapidly moving Matt from scene to scene in his own mind (at least I think it's just in his mind; some of it seemed pretty real). Because of the nature of the gas, it's hard to tell if Mr. Fear remembers that Matt is Daredevil—although given the end of the issue, I think that question is a moot point anyway.
I liked the idea that Cranston tried to find financial backing for Valor—it's either find a partner or rob a few banks to fund it, right? As the current Kingpin-type, of course, Tombstone would be one of the people he'd approach. But the reveal that it's really Harlan Vale, the man who's been making the hairs on the back of Matt's neck stand up every time he's around, makes perfect sense. He's clearly got larger goals he's working towards than just donating a bunch of money to the university, and that's starting to become clear now.
Lastly, we check in with Detective Forte. The two officers with him at the latest crime scene are carrying on a conversation about Valor, and how useful it could be to them and other first responders. Is this an acceptable conversation to have at a crime scene where someone died from Valor use? Of course not. But it's very human of them.
Forte might want to grab a couple of pills for himself, actually. He keeps seeing Omen everywhere, and that's going to have to come to a head soon, I think.
Silent Partner
Stephanie Phillips tells another strong story here, with Mr. Fear being presented as a scary presence who really puts Matt through the wringer. The new fear gas puts Matt in such a state that we are left as off-balance as he is throughout the course of the issue, questioning what is really happening to him and what is not. The Vale reveal is unsurprising but is a big step forward in the overall story she's been telling, and the cliffhanger isn't going to make things any easier for Matt going forward.
Lee Garbett's art continues to give this book a distinctive look. While Matt is under the influence of the fear gas, Garbett makes his panel layouts even more varied than the norm, which adds to the feeling of being off-balance. The horror on Matt's face when he finds out he's been attacking Foggy really sells just how off-balance the gas has him. And although I really miss Mr. Fear's old mask, the new one certainly does allow him more expression and a very unsettling look overall.
Frank Martin's colors once again tie together all of Garbett's imagery. Here, thanks to the fear gas, everything is just a bit off or wrong throughout the issue. None of the colors are exactly what they should be, and it adds to Matt's state of mind. It can't be easy to make blood stand out against a bright red suit like Daredevil's, but Martin manages to do it here and makes the scene where Matt thinks he's beating Foggy particularly powerful.
Pierce the Veil
Daredevil #9 is a wild ride through the inner fears of Matt Murdock, as he's dosed with Mr. Fear's newest gas and forced to relive all of his guilt and loss. Matt is no stranger to fear, so the villain may not be able to completely break him—but Mr. Fear can certainly make things a lot more complicated for Matt...