Action Comics #1104 - Lex Luthor: Year One - Part Two
Written by Mark Waid
Art and Colors by Patricio Delpeche
Letters by Steve Wands
Cover Art by Chris Brunner and Rico Renzi
How does someone become a monster? How does evil take root in someone’s soul? How could someone so smart, so brilliant, so gifted… become one of the most dastardly villains the DC Universe has ever seen? Mark Waid’s new take on Lex Luthor’s origin continues in Action Comics #1104 and provides us with a look at how Lex's family and his relationships with them changed everything for a young man who just needed a little more love in his life. Spoiler Warning Now In Effect for Action Comics #1104!
Life on the Road
At the end of the last issue, Lex and his mother, Leticia, escaped the abusive Lionel Luthor by faking their deaths in a house fire. Leticia saw no other way out for her and her son, and we now join them in their journey to find a home. To find somewhere for them where they can be safe and away from Lionel. Unfortunately, even fantasy worlds like the DC universe can be unforgiving to everyday folks and it’s implied that it's very tough for Leticia to earn enough money to support her and her incredibly gifted son.
Lex has always been brilliant, and this issue does a wonderful job of highlighting how smart he really is. If he just had a fragment of empathy in that heart of his, I can only imagine how much the DC Universe would have benefited from his genius, but when you have an upbringing like he had, you can see why he became the person who has tormented Superman at every chance he gets. With Leticia struggling to get some stable ground for her son and herself to stand on, it falls to Lex to try to bring some money in for them, and for the first time, we see how his smarts can be his salvation in the form of some cold, hard cash.
A youth science fair in Gotham promises a $25,000 prize to the winner, and Lex develops an artificial pancreas, thanks to some “five-finger discounted” items Leticia took from a local hospital. It’s a genius invention, especially for someone of Lex’s age, and a local doctor named Thomas marvels at how someone so young was able to create something so advanced. Unfortunately, Thomas (a doctor) and his wife Martha put together that the parts Lex’s used were stolen, and after Lex strikes their son across the face, Leticia and Lex are forced to flee Gotham before they’re caught.
Thomas? Martha? A son? Yeah, that’s a pretty cool cameo and one I didn’t expect to find in this book. I also looked at this section of the issue another way. Thomas Wayne immediately recognizes the brilliance Lex Luthor possesses, and there is an alternate timeline out there where his genius is backed by someone like Thomas, and Lex’s inventions are put to good use to help folks almost immediately. Unfortunately, like most things in Lex’s early life, things don’t seem to work out for the better, and a potential life of service is stopped before it can ever get started. This section by Waid not only offered a fun cameo, but gave us readers a tiny little window into another road that Lex may have gone down if life was just a little different for him. Waid presenting Lex as this tragic figure resonates well with me, and I think it will for all of you as well.
Loneliness in Different Forms
We cut away from Lex and Leticia for his next bit of the issue and check in on a young Clark Kent as he continues to navigate life in the American heartland. It’s Christmas time in Smallville, and at the local mall it's time for Clark to meet Jolly Ol’ Saint Nick. When it comes time for him to ask Santa what he wants for Christmas, Clark doesn’t want just any old toy or video games; he wants a brother. Needless to say, this is a very complicated situation for Jonathan and Martha Kent. They don’t want their son to feel lonely but they understand the complications that can arise from not only Clark having to keep his immense secret but having a second child keep it as well. Clark might one day have friends and family and people he can be himself around, but as a kid in Smallville, Kansas, that’s still years away for him. Martha and Jonathan do their best to make their son feel better, but it’s clear that the loneliness is taking its toll on Clark as he does his best to try to cheer himself up.
Clark and Lex are both very different kids, and as adults they couldn’t be more different, but at their core as children they’re both very lonely. Clark has a loving family and an amazing support system, but as a kid it's killing him inside that he can’t really play sports or interact with a lot of the other kids his age because of his powers. Lex, with all the brains, smarts, and ambition in the world, just didn’t have the caring upbringing he needed, and now, on the run with his mother and not finding peace at any turn, he doesn’t have the emotional support he sorely needs. Two kids, two entirely different upbringings, but loneliness is something that plagues them both. One of them ultimately uses those feelings to make sure no one ever feels loneliness or pain, while the other never obtained the empathy he so sorely needed. If you take one thing from this new origin for Lex Luthor, understand that fact that he was a few instances away from becoming an entirely different person if only his father could’ve seen how incredible his son was.
The Light of his Life
Shifting back to Lex, we learn that Leticia and her son made their way back to Lionel Luthor after a computer hack magically erased their death certificates. Lex and Leticia realize that, even if Lionel is a garbage human being, they need to keep up the “facade of a loving family” to survive. Lex makes a comment that everything he learned about manipulation comes from his parents. Reading that really makes you feel sad for the guy because even though we know the monster he becomes, reading that line is heartbreaking. Parents are supposed to be beacons of hope and love and light for their children, not being examples or how to manipulate anyone. Just another way that Lex’s folks failed him and why he never had a chance to become the best version of himself. A new addition to the Luthor family is a welcome addition to Lex’s life: his sister Lena.
Leticia gives birth to a baby girl, and Lex absolutely adores his baby sister. Lena, as Lex says, “was the light of his life. He learns what it feels like to feel unconditional love for someone, and he begins to teach her all he knows and cultivates her intelligence as best as he can. For someone who didn’t have the best examples of love in his life so far, he does a damn good job of caring for Lena and giving her the support he always should have had. Unfortunately, as is the case in the young life of Lex Luthor, things take a turn for the worse. Waid continues to do a fantastic job making us understand how the man became the monster
Lena and Lex continue to grow up together for a few years, and things continue on relatively normal until one morning Lena wakes up and she can’t feel her legs. Doctors determine she developed a paralytic illness that took away the use of her legs, and Lex tries his damnedest to find a cure for his little sister. We cut back to Lex writing his memoir in the present day and we get one of the most powerful selections of panels in this issue that give us an in-depth look at Luthor’s psyche in just a few short words. Lex is about to write that he failed his sister, but he can’t bring himself to write it down. He spends an entire day and night staring at his computer screen before eventually deleting that he failed her and blames it entirely on the unsuccessful medicines available at that time. Lex cannot bear to write down that he failed his sister. He can’t bear to write down that he let the person who meant the most to him down. He can’t bear to shoulder any of the responsibility for not being able to make her healthy again. In just five panels, we can see how much Lena’s illness continues to weigh on the man who sits above the Metropolis skyline, and you can just glimpse the feelings of empathy in him within that moment. You also glimpse the fact that Lex can never let things go. Patricio Delpeche’s layout and idea for this scene were fantastic, and kudos to the artist for his brilliant work not just in this section but for some amazing work in this issue.
Lena’s illness ultimately causes the Luthor family to break apart once again, and this time, there is no Leticia to help Lex pick up the pieces. After a brawl between Lex and his father that begins when Lionel threatens Lena, Lex uses a prototype exo-suit meant to help his sister walk again to beat the crap out of his father. His mother feels she has seen enough violence in her life and takes Lena away from the home and away from Lex. She abandons him with his father and takes away the one person who lit up his life. Needless to say, this event further breaks down Lex and sets him further down the path of darkness. I can’t even imagine what Lex is going through when he opens the front door of his home and sees Lena and his mother gone. Maybe his last hopes for a normal life are all but gone. The sad part of this is, as Lex tells us, he and his father finally have something in common: hating his mother. Can you imagine the one thing you have in common with your dad is hating your mother? Life just isn’t kind to the young man, and as this issue goes on it continues to become more and more apparent why he is the way he is. Next stop for Lex: Metropolis.
A Return to Smallville
Lex negotiates with two of his father’s cousins to stay with them and befriends a suspiciously familiar-looking puppy that I just can’t seem to put my finger on who it might be… Lex means to collect the life insurance policies on his cousins (because of course that’s what he wants to do) and creates an explosive device to help him get that money at some point. One night, as Lex is coming back, it accidentally goes off early, but he manages to save the dog trapped in his room. Life insurance fraud? Keeping a sweet puppy trapped? Scheming to get his money no matter who it hurts? There’s the Lex Luthor we all know. With no place to go in Metropolis and no family left to turn to, Lex Luthor returns to Smallville after hearing about the appearance of someone called Superboy…
Action Comics #1104 peels back the layers of Lex Luthor’s childhood even more and further helps us understand how he becomes the monster we all know. Fleeting moments of happiness are not enough to stop the loss of Luthor’s empathy as he grows up. Mark Waid understands Lex Luthor just as well as he understands Superman, and with some incredible artwork from Patricio Delpeche, this issue is a great second part to Action Comics’ current arc.