It is All In week, and I decided to go down memory lane and compile what I think are the ten best matches in the history of the pay-per-view. There have been enough editions of All In , and enough matches to sift through, to pick the ten best. Obviously ‘best’ is subjective. My definition is in-ring quality, importance, and legacy: matches that help tell AEW’s story, matches that rank among the best wrestling we have ever seen, and matches I’m especially partial to. All of these matches have carved their own little corner in AEW lore and have been immortalized.
Since the revival of the monumental PPV was announced in 2020 and it became part of the AEW PPV family, Tony Khan set out to make this event his own version of “WrestleMania.” A place where stars are born, moments are made, and AEW continues to grow. This list also gives me a chance to reminisce and see how far this company has come. While only four years old and with five different iterations of the event, All In has become the tentpole for the alternative company.
Photo credit: ROH.
10. Kenny Omega vs Penta El 0 (All In 2018)
This match was a clear precursor to what AEW was all about in its early years. Everything that everyone loves about All Elite Wrestling was front and center in this match. Kenny Omega came into the match as the IWGP World Heavyweight Champion, but did not defend it. Pentagon, Penta El Zero, or whatever name you want to call him, came to play and, in one of his first big spotlights, performed as one of the best wrestlers in the world. This was the first singles match between two of the most important wrestlers in AEW history, and it became one of the best and most important matches of AEW's early years.
The crowd was so hot for this match, and they were loving every minute. Both Penta and Omega were fighting for the love of the game, and it showed. The entire event was the seed for what would later grow into something. The wrestling style, in-ring storytelling, and all of it was pure AEW. The match doesn't get talked about as much as other pre-AEW matches are, given its importance to the promotion's creation.
Just as important were the post-match developments, as Chris Jericho, dressed as Penta, attacked Omega, starting their path toward a historic rivalry that carried the baton between All In and Double or Nothing.
Photo credit: AEW.
9. AEW World Championship: MJF def. Adam Cole (All In 2024)
100 years from now, when you're telling the story of All Elite Wrestling, you won't be able to tell the rise of AEW without talking about the main event between Adam Cole and MJF. Cole vs. MJF for the AEW Men’s World Championship is still one of the biggest main events in AEW history, and it looked massive. If you rewatch it, both entrances looked like the biggest deal in the world, and that crowd looked like an endless sea of people.
In retrospect, having Adam Cole main event this match was a bittersweet moment for a wrestler who might never get in the ring again, and he was able to share the spotlight with his '“best friend.” This is the original mega-match in AEW. While other matches have had better drama or better in-ring wrestling, this was the first one in AEW that felt like the biggest thing in the world. The presentation set the standard, and it also gave wrestlers a different path to their “WrestleMania” moment.
So while the match was fun, melodramatic, and goofy at times, the real success of this match, at least for me, was its presentation and the standard it set for the rest of All In.
Photo credit: AEW.
8. Casino Gauntlet (All In 2024)
While AEW had had Casino Gauntlets before All In 2024, this was easily the biggest and most well-received of them all. There was so much going on in this Gauntlet that, on rewatch, you can see why so many people fell in love with this gimmick match that night. Nigel McGuinness made his return to the wrestling ring, Ricochet made his official debut in AEW, and Zack Sabre Jr. was able to wrestle in front of his fellow countrymen and women. By the way, before we move on, a small piece of me likes to think the Casino Gauntlet was brought to London just for McGuinness.
Christian Cage ended up winning the contract for the No. 1 Contendorship, and while Cage cashing it in was a big wet fart, it did set the tone for the rest of the Casino Gauntlet winners moving forward. All In 2024 was the one that shined the brightest and set the standard for the rest of them in the future. This Casino Gauntlet was so well received at All In 2024 that it has now become a staple at the biggest show of the year, and this year’s version might be able to top it.
Photo credit: AEW.
7. AEW Women’s World Championship: Toni Storm def. Mercedes Mone (All In 2025)
Mercedes Mone vs Toni Storm at All In 2025 felt special. On a night full of megastars, it was mentioned as a co-main event alongside Kazuchika Okada vs Kenny Omega and Adam Page vs Jon Moxley. That shows how well these competitors were regarded and how important this match was for the women’s division. I think I like this match so much because we all thought we were going to witness Mercedes’ crowning moment, finally becoming AEW Women’s World Champion and adding to her 15 titles. Instead, it became a Toni Storm moment, as she was recognized as the cornerstone of the women’s division. Storm didnt beat Mone in a fluke way either; it was a deceptive pin to leave no doubt.
This loss started Mercedes's downfall; she went on to lose every single belt after this, then started the rise again after winning the Owen Hart Cup for the second consecutive year. This match not only cemented Storm as the best-ever AEW Women’s World Champion, but it smashed any notion that Mercedes was “Hulking” and politicking her way in the locker room. Most importantly, it was the ultimate showcase for two women who bet on themselves and went against the grain on AEW’s biggest stage.
Photo credit: AEW.
6. AEW Unified Championship: Kazuchika Okada def. Kenny Omega (All In 2025)
When Tony Khan announced he had purchased the rights to Ring of Honor in 2022, and by default the rights back to the original All In, Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada was likely the match he had in mind. This was the biggest match, as far as lore goes, that All In has ever hosted, and AEW did a fantastic job recapping Okada and Omega’s past feud for an audience that perhaps wasn't fully dialed in. This is where AEW turned the corner in recapping feuds and storylines.
This was billed as the co-main event for the night, and with good reason. Both Okada and Omega received superstar entrances, and this was the biggest version of this rivalry to date. Was this match as athletic or physically impressive as their first four match-ups? No. That said, this was the most methodical, calculated, and thought-out match of the five fights. It was structured as though both men knew every move, with neither wanting to make a mistake. This was built up as the biggest match ever, as the winner would take home the International and Continental Championships as the Unified Champion.
Okada is now up 3-2 in the series. Still, this won't be the last match we see between these two bitter, lifelong rivals.
Photo credit: AEW.
5. International Championship: Will Ospreay def. MJF (All In 2024)
In what might preview what happens this weekend, Will Ospreay vs. MJF was the original homecoming moment for the British wrestler. MJF had beaten Ospreay for the International Championship and renamed it the American Championship because, of course, he did. While it wasn't the main event of All In that year, it was treated like a co-main event, with fireworks and an over-the-top presentation for Ospreay. Ospreay still wasn't officially signed to AEW yet, as that announcement came four months later, in November 2024. Tony Khan pulled out all of the stops for Ospreay to make him feel at home in AEW.
This was one of many fantastic wrestling matches these two men have had against each other. MJF and Ospreay seem to bring out the best in each other, and this match, in the brightest of spotlights, proved that they need to keep this rivalry alive.
The Tiger Driver ‘91 was a big point of the storyline, and when Ospreay hit it on MJF, after some assistance from a returning Daniel Garcia, Ospreay got his International Title once again, and the hometown boy got his major moment.
Could this be how All In 2026 ends, with Ospreay standing over the ring with new gold above his head?
Photo credit: AEW.
4. CM Punk vs Samoa Joe (All In 2023)
The opening match of the first reincarnation of All In was a great match between two old rivals set to kick off the biggest show in the young company's history. The pressure was on them, and because of their professionalism, they knocked it out of the park. Add in that CM Punk had just gotten into a ‘fight’ with Jack Perry in Gorilla, and Punk knew this was likely his last match for AEW and probably wasn't in the right mindset; still, with Samoa Joe, he had one of the more memorable in-ring matches in All In history. I couldn't even imagine what was going through Joe’s mind.
These two opponents were a great choice to reintroduce what All In meant. Both competitors had deep roots with Ring of Honor, had a deep-seated rivalry, and knew how to work a great match for the fans. The win for Punk was supposed to kick off his “Real World Champion” storyline, which was going to be a good one. Instead, with his left fist raised to the air, the last we ever saw of CM Punk in AEW was him leaving through the tunnel, back to the fans, with the “real” championship over his right shoulder—an iconic picture for an iconic match.
Photo credit: AEW.
3. Young Bucks vs Swerve Strickland/Will Ospreay
Picture it: Arlington, June 2025, at Globe Life Field. I brought my AEW-agnostic brother for two reasons: he's my brother, and I wanted to show him what AEW was all about. He wasn't the biggest wrestling fan, but he was invested in WWE at the time, around Rock v. Cody Rhodes, so he tuned in. He also likes to troll me and rib me for liking AEW. That changed when Swerve/Ospreay vs. The Young Bucks started. He was already having a good time, but this tag match changed his view of the promotion. It is the perfect encapsulation of what AEW is all about in the ring.
There was so much to fight for, so I don't think many people believed Ospreay/Swerve were going to win, but they pulled it out, and this was the climax of the founding fathers gimmick, going out with a bang. In-ring, this is some of the best wrestling in an AEW ring. The jaw-dropping moves, acrobatics, and near falls are what make AEW so great, and in this match they were dialed up and baselined right into our veins. If it made a believer out of my brother, it still has a chance to convert hardened AEW skeptics.
Photo credit: AEW.
2. AEW World Championship: Bryan Danielson def. (C) Swerve Strickland (All In 2024)
No wrestling promotion in the world tells a fairytale ending better. From Sting to Bryan Danielson, All Elite Wrestling knows how to care for its wrestling legends, letting them go out on top while they hold up wrestling gold and are carried off into the sunset by the fans and the locker room. Though not his official last match, this match will be remembered as his swan song, where, even if he didn't want them, he was given flowers as one of the best wrestlers of this generation and of all time.
From the get-go, the entire city of London could be heard singing The Final Countdown all the way to Neptune. What a feeling that must have been for Danielson. They were hot and stayed with the sentimental favorite for 30 minutes. The match highlighted what made Danielson one of the best of all time, as he took it to the ground and put on a masterclass in technical wrestling. Begrudgingly, Danielson won the title in front of his family and cemented his legacy as one of the best wrestlers of this, or any, generation. While he might make sporadic appearances here and there, this was the perfect send-off to the only best.
Photo credit: AEW.
1. AEW World Championship: “Hangman” Adam Page def. Jon Moxley (All In 2025)
There might be some pushback to this, but I don't think AEW has ever done a better main event than this Texas Death Match. I know the double debut of Adam Cole and Bryan Danielson has been cemented in many people's minds as the best ending to an AEW show, but for my money (which is not a lot), it's when Hangman did his job and hung Moxley over the top rope. What a visual. Those moments are exactly why Tony Khan brought back All In and made it AEW's “WrestleMania.” If there were any questions about which PPV was the crown jewel, All In 2025 erased any doubt.
The match itself was historic, of course, and that is part of why it stands above the rest. Having a Death Match as your main event at your biggest show of the year was a risk, given how the Exploding Barbed Wire had gone, but it went off without a hitch.
Perhaps my opinion is colored, as I was there live in Arlington, but seeing the Cowboy lift the belt after his climb to the top and the belt being held captive in a suitcase for the better part of a year was deeply satisfying. Not only that, but seeing the return of both Darby Allin and Bryan Danielson, exacting their revenge on the same Death Riders that took them out, was cathartic.
This match will live in the annals of AEW lore, as there was only one result that mattered, and it is exactly what we got. All across the country, people could be heard cheering for the Cowboy finally freeing us from our Death Rider purgatory.
